How to Run an EHR Evaluation With a Clinical Team

A four-week EHR evaluation: who to involve, the three workflows to test end to end, a scoring sheet you can copy, and the traps that waste a year.

Ona Health team

13 min read

Share

An EHR evaluation should take four weeks and test three workflows, not forty features. Ona Health gives every evaluation a 14-day free trial with full access and no credit card, which is long enough to chart a visit, sign the note and watch a claim build from the chart in insurance eligibility and claims before anybody signs anything.

Quick answer:

  • Four people, one owner: a clinician who signs notes, whoever answers the phone, whoever works the claims, and one person who holds the calendar and makes the call.
  • Three workflows, each run by the person who will live with it: new patient to booked, visit to signed note, note to paid claim. A feature nobody touched in the trial scores zero.
  • Four weeks: two days to shortlist, one week of vendor calls, two weeks hands-on, one week for references and the decision. Then start payer enrollment at once, because Ona's help centre tells its own customers that enrollments take weeks with payers.

Who sits on the evaluation, and who does not

Evaluations fail at the staffing stage, before anyone has seen a product: one person decides alone, or eleven get a vote and the project dies of scheduling.

Four roles carry a vote. The clinician who writes the most notes, not the most senior one. Whoever answers the phone and books, the only person who can say whether a booking rule survives a patient asking for 4pm on a Thursday. Whoever works the claims, the most commonly excluded voter and the most expensive to exclude: if your billing is outsourced, put the partner inside the trial, because on Ona a staff seat is $45 a month and works the same Claims queue your own team sees. And one owner, who holds the calendar, keeps the sheet and breaks ties. Without a named owner an evaluation has no end date.

Workflow one: new patient to booked

Bring a real case: someone never seen, with insurance you actually bill, asking for a service you actually sell. Then watch the handoffs. Does the patient reach a bookable time without a phone call? Does intake land on the chart before the visit, or does somebody retype it?

Name the mechanism, not the feature. On Ona that is the booking page, where patients pick a service, clinician, location and time and can pay as they book with a 30-minute hold on the slot; online scheduling rules that stack across five levels (practice, site, room, clinician and service) and can only get stricter going down; and intake forms that score screeners such as PHQ-9 and GAD-7 on submit.

If the phone is the bottleneck, test it the same week. Ona's AI receptionist is the only separately priced AI add-on, from $100 a month for 400 included minutes and $0.20 a minute beyond, and it books only after confirming an existing patient by name plus a date of birth, phone number or email.

Pass test: a new patient books, pays and arrives with intake charted, and nobody typed anything twice.

Workflow two: visit to signed note

Vendors demo this best and buyers test it worst: a note from a scripted recording is easy to admire, one from your own messy visit is not.

Record a genuine visit, generate the note in your own template, and write down two numbers: the time from the end of the visit to a signed note, and how many passages the clinician rewrote by hand.

On Ona the published figure here is zero. No note is drafted before a clinician picks a template and chooses Generate. There are three ways to start, blank, generated or copied forward, and after the draft every AI edit is a suggestion you Keep or Discard, with Sign waiting until you do. A supervising clinician adds their signature with Add my signature, and a signed note changes only by amendment, with a reason and a diff. AI charting and the ambient scribe sit inside the $130 practitioner seat, with no charge per note.

Three questions the deck rarely answers: who can edit a signed note, what happens to passages the AI could not fill, and whether drafting carries a per-clinician fee. As checked on November 18, 2026, SimplePractice prices its AI Note Taker at $35 a month and Jane its AI Scribe at USD $15 per opted-in practitioner.

Workflow three: note to paid claim

The workflow that decides the purchase and the one most evaluations skip, because it cannot be demoed in ten minutes. Carry in two cases: a clean insured visit, and a claim your current system got denied.

Then insist on seeing each link. Does the claim build from what was charted, or does a biller rekey codes into a second system, and when a denial comes back, where does it land?

On Ona, eligibility runs when a patient books, when their insurance changes and again in the 48 hours before an insured visit, and a Needs verification list collects any insured visit missing a check or a confirmed copay. What was charted flows into the draft claim, billing rules flag what would bounce, and the published number is zero again: Ona sends zero claims to a payer without someone on your team choosing Submit. Remittances post paid, allowed and denied amounts to each claim line, and the patient's invoice re-prices in billing and payments.

The money here is metered, so ask about it everywhere. Ona Clearing House runs on Stedi with no separate account to open, contract or pay for, from $69 a month for 100 claims, 100 ERAs and 200 eligibility checks up to $1,099 for 2,500 claims, with unlimited providers and payer enrollments on every plan, and cash-pay practices need none. Two limits: Ona submits professional claims only, as CMS-1500 and 837P, not UB-04, and live submission waits on payer enrollment.

Pass test: your biller rebuilds the denied claim in the trial, with its attachment, and can say why it will not bounce twice. Background: how real-time eligibility checks work and reducing claim denials.

The scoring sheet you can copy

Write it and weight it before the first demo, and do not change the weights once scoring starts. Each criterion is scored 0 to 5 by the person who ran it, then multiplied by its weight.

  • New patient to booked, weight 20, scored by the front desk or scheduler. A 5 means booked, paid, intake charted, nothing retyped.
  • Visit to signed note, weight 20, scored by the clinician who signs the most notes. A 5 means signed in their own template, with the assessment untouched by the AI.
  • Note to paid claim, weight 20, scored by the biller or the billing partner. A 5 means the denied claim rebuilt and the flags caught before submission.
  • Getting your data out, weight 10, scored by the owner. A 5 means the export format and any fee in writing, from the old vendor and the new one.
  • A price you can read, weight 10, scored by the owner. A 5 means seats and add-ons published, so the monthly number is arithmetic.
  • Administrative control, weight 10, scored by the owner. A 5 means roles, access and the activity log checked by a non-clinician.
  • What they put in writing, weight 10, scored by the owner. A 5 means support hours and stated limits as documents, not reassurance.

Two rules make it work. Only the person who ran a workflow scores it, so a demo promise is worth zero until your team reproduces it, and scores go in the same day, before the warmest salesperson starts winning ties.

How long each stage should take

Four weeks is enough for most practices if the stages run in this order and the trials overlap.

Days 1 to 2: shortlist. Three vendors, never six, chosen from published prices and limits alone, which needs no calls. Pick by practice shape: choosing an EHR by practice size covers what breaks at each size.

Week 1: vendor calls. One hour each, your three workflows as the agenda, sent in advance, the same four people in the room. A vendor who cannot hold that agenda has told you something worth scoring. The questions worth asking on that call are in what to ask on an EHR demo.

Weeks 2 and 3: hands-on. Trials in parallel, with real cases. Ona gives 14 days with full access and no credit card, runnable alongside your current system, and migrates from any EHR at no cost, typically within one business day. As checked on November 18, 2026, Healthie publishes 14 days on its Plus plan, SimplePractice a trial its page says keeps going to 30 days, and Jane no trial at all.

Week 4: references and the decision. Two calls with practices of your size and payer mix, one question each: what surprised you in month two. Then the owner totals the sheet.

Immediately after: payer enrollment. Ona's own help centre tells its customers that enrollments are gated on insurance setup and "take weeks with payers, so start them early". That is the best argument for deciding in four weeks rather than four months. What migrates and what never does is in what switching EHR actually takes. What the first four weeks after signing look like is in EHR implementation, weeks one to four.

What you can check before anyone gets on a call

Ona Health is a general ambulatory EHR and practice management platform, solo clinician through enterprise group, and the one honest exclusion is inpatient and hospital work. That line, the price and the trial should all be establishable in ten minutes without a call. Every figure below was read on the vendor's own live pricing page on November 18, 2026, Jane at ?locale=en-US. It shows what each vendor lets you verify before a sales conversation, not a quality ranking.

PlatformPublished starting priceTrial you can start yourselfPriced separately on the same page
Ona Health$130 per practitioner seat, $45 per staff seat, 10% off annually, no setup fee or contract; 2 practitioners plus 1 staff seat is $30514 days, full access, no credit cardE-prescribing $45, EPCS $25, Omnichannel $150 (free at two practitioners or fewer), AI receptionist from $100, clearing house $69 to $1,099
SimplePracticeStarter $49, Essential $79, Plus $99; group $99 for the first practitioner plus $74 each; its page ran 50% off for 3 months on the as-checked date, Starter $24.50 then $49Free trial the page says keeps going to 30 daysAI Note Taker $35, Care Aide $59 plus $49 per extra clinician, ePrescribe $49 plus $89 setup, claims $1.79 each
HealthieEssentials $49.99, Plus $129.99, Group $149.99 and up monthly, plus $50 per extra clinician; 10% off annually, Essentials $45, Plus $115, Group $135 and up14 days on the Plus plan, no credit cardClaimMD integration $25 to $30 (the page states both) plus a $50 to $100 setup fee, payments 2.9% plus $0.30
JaneUSD $59 Balance (one practitioner profile, capped at 20 appointments a month, no insurance billing add-on), USD $79 Practice, USD $99 Thrive, plus per-practitioner licence feesNone. The page states there is no free trialInsurance Billing USD $20 plus $5 per full-time or $2.50 per part-time practitioner, AI Scribe USD $15, Group Telehealth USD $15
TebraNot published; the page says pricing is tailored during the demo processNone publishedEPCS setup about $75 per provider, PDMP $500 per facility plus about $50 per user a year

Healthie no longer publishes a $19.99 Core tier, so on this shortlist the cheapest published starting point is SimplePractice Starter, $49 a month at standard price and $24.50 for the first three months on the promotion its page ran on November 18, 2026. And a published entry price is not a configured price: the add-on column is where the real monthly number gets decided.

The traps that cost practices a year

The demo-driven decision. A demo is a rehearsed path through a product by the person who knows it best. Use demos to filter the shortlist, and score no criterion from something you only watched.

The feature checklist nobody uses. Every serious vendor ticks almost every row, so the list hides what matters: whether work survives a handoff. Whether an old signed note arrives as a structured field or a PDF file. Whether the biller works in the same record as the clinician. Who is told when a claim is denied.

Skipping the billing path. The expensive one, because clinical software gets judged on charting and paid for out of collections. If you bill insurance and never touch a claim in the trial, you have bought a charting tool and will meet the rest at go-live. Scoring the headline price. Build the configured monthly number, with every add-on you will switch on in year one. On Ona that is published arithmetic: $305 for two practitioners plus one staff seat, plus $45 and $25 per prescribing practitioner for controlled substances, plus $100 for 400 receptionist minutes, plus a clearing house plan from $69 if you bill insurance. Where a vendor publishes none, record that as the answer.

Frequently asked questions

How long should an EHR evaluation take?

Four weeks from shortlist to decision, then one to three weeks of cutover for a smaller practice: two days to shortlist, one week of vendor calls, two weeks hands-on, one week for references and the call. The clock you do not control is payer enrollment, and Ona Health's help centre tells its own customers that enrollments take weeks with payers.

Who should be on an EHR evaluation team?

Four people: a clinician who signs notes, whoever answers the phone and books, whoever works the claims, and one owner who holds the calendar and makes the call. Everyone else is consulted, not a voter. If billing is outsourced, put the partner inside the trial, because on Ona a staff seat is $45 a month and works the same Claims queue your team sees.

What should we test in an EHR trial?

Three workflows end to end, with real cases: new patient to booked, visit to signed note, note to paid claim. Each crosses a handoff where software actually fails, and each is run by a different person on your team. A feature nobody touched during the trial scores zero, however good the demo looked.

How do you score EHR vendors without the loudest voice winning?

Weight the sheet before the first demo: 60 points for the three workflows, and 10 each for getting your data out, a price you can read without a sales call, administrative control, and what the vendor puts in writing. Only the person who ran a workflow scores it, and scores go in the same day.

Can we test insurance billing before we buy?

On Ona, yes, up to the payer. The 14-day free trial has full access, so you can chart a visit, sign the note, watch the claim build from the chart and read what the billing rules flag, and Ona sends zero claims to a payer without someone choosing Submit. Live adjudication waits on payer enrollment.

Next step

Pick your three workflows, name your four people and set a decision date before the first demo. Then bring one real new patient, one real visit and one real denial to a 15-minute demo, or start the 14-day free trial and run them yourself. Current prices are on the pricing page.

Written by

Ona Health team

Related reading

Keep exploring.

13 min read

Ona Health at a Glance: What It Is, Who It Is For, What It Costs

Ona Health at a glance: the category, practice sizes, the 19 product areas, full published pricing from $130 per practitioner, and what it does not do.

Ona Health team
13 min read

Ona Health vs Pabau (2026): Which Fits a US Ambulatory Practice?

Ona Health vs Pabau in 2026: published prices, the US insurance cycle, prescribing, AI scribes, and which platform fits a US ambulatory practice.

Ona Health team
12 min read

The Eight Questions That Get a Real EHR Price Before the Demo

Eight questions force a line-item EHR price out of a quote, each with a published benchmark, checked 18 November 2026. Ona Health publishes all of its.

Ona Health team

See Ona in action.

One platform for scheduling, charting, billing and insurance. Try everything free for 14 days — no credit card required.